Allan Wilfred Rule (Allan in electoral roll; Alan in printed material) was born in Melbourne on the 22nd July 1907 to Albert Carlos (1873 – 1955) and Gertrude Mary (nee Samblebe 1880 – 1961) Rule.
In 1929 he married divorcee Beryl Jean Brook (nee Brandon) who died in Melbourne in 1982.
Allan Rule enlisted 23rd February 1942 in the Royal Australian Navy as a Seaman (#25683) and a member of the Marine Corps Band in Melbourne (N.O.K. Beryl Rule). He was a huge man whose naval career ended when he suffered a back injury as a result of a fall down the metal stairs of a ship. He was discharged on 14th March 1946.

Allan Rule came to Perth from Melbourne in 1947 and played Principal Clarinet with the West Australian Symphony Orchestra until 1966 when he stepped down to second clarinet due to ill health, retiring in 1971 and Jack Harrison moved to the Principal Clarinet position.
Allan Rule was taught clarinet by his father who was in one of the theatre orchestras.
Weston, Pamela, Clarinet Virtuosi of Today, (Egon,1989). p.305
Pen Points on Perth By Harry Bluck
IT RUNS IN THE FAMILY
Music is an integral part of the Harrison family, as veteran pianist Bill Harrison is Jack Harrison‘s proud poppa, a sister plays piano in Jack’s outfit while a brother wields the drumsticks. Jack is being ably coached in his sax work by Ken Murdoch, while he is also studying “legit” clarinet with A.B.C. woodwindist Alan Rule. Apart from these few activities, plus his harmonica appearances, plus his home rehearsals, plus his rehearsals with the A.B.C. Amateur Symphony Group, plus his private practice – Jack still finds time to be a modest 15 year old Aussie. All his many friends in local musical circles predict quite a musical future for young Jack – so we wish him the best of luck!!
Music Maker July 21 1947
MUSIC and THEATRE By “FIDELIO”
Noted for listening: Tomorrow, 8.45 p.m.: Perth String Quartet and Allan Rule in Mozart’s Clarinet Quintet. At this afternoon’s meeting of the Kylie Club the Moongana Singers will be heard, and Mozart’s Clarinet Quintet will be played.
West Australian (Perth, WA : 1879 – 1954), Saturday 19 July 1947, page 5
CHILDREN HEAR ORCHESTRA
Children from State and private schools filled the Midland Junction Town Hall on Wednesday afternoon and the Fremantle Town Hall yesterday afternoon to listen to music. On each occasion the Perth Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Henry Krips, played a programme comprising the “Fingal’s Cave” overture (Mendelssohn), “Finlandia” (Sibelius). Scherzo and Finale from Beethoven’s Fifth Symphony, and Concertino for Clarinet and Orchestra (Weber), in which Alan Rule was soloist. The Superintendent of Music in State Schools (Mr. O. G. Campbell Egan) spoke to the children about the orchestra and led them in songs. The concerts were given by the Australian Broadcasting Commission.
West Australian (Perth, WA : 1879 – 1954), Friday 4 June 1948, page 12
RECITAL BY SOPRANO (By “Fidelio.”)
At her best, Betty Hatfield achieved some musical effects of prettiness and charm in the vocal recital she gave last night, conspicuously so in Schubert’s “The Shepherd on the Rock” (Alan Rule‘s clarinet part contributing to the success). In the early part of Mozart’s “Non Mi Dir” also she was happily effective. On the other hand there was evident rather often in her ambitious programme the need for sustained firmness and “body” in tones and phrases, for the want of which her performances were apt to lack convincing character. Miss Hatfield sang opera excerpts from Gluck (two), Mozart and Leoncavallo, Caccini’s “Amarilli,” three Schubert songs and two each by Armstrong Gibbs and Roger Quilter. She was accompanied by Keith Carter, who also played solos by Schumann and Scriabin. The recital was given in the rooms of the Women’s Service Guilds, Sherwood Court.
West Australian (Perth, WA : 1879 – 1954), Saturday 27 November 1948, page 11
Works to be heard at tomorrow’s meeting of the Minnawarra Chamber Music Club are Beethoven’s Trio, Op. 11, for piano (Nora Coalstad), ‘cello (Zlata Kalmikoff) and clarinet (Alan Rule); Debussy’s “Fetes Galantes” sung by Merle Arundale, and Goossens’s “Five Impressions of a Holiday,” for piano, ‘cello and flute (Douglas Whittaker).
West Australian (Perth, WA : 1879 – 1954), Saturday 6 August 1949, page 19
MUSIC AND THEATRE – By T.C.M.
At this afternoon’s meeting of the Kylie Music Club the approach of Christmas will be heralded by the Ladies’ Odeon Choir, conducted by Mrs. N. E. Moran, which has included carols and other Christmas songs in its programme. Allan Rule and Robert Trew will be heard in clarinet duets by A. Frank and Poulenc. The programme has been arranged by Vaughan Hanly.
West Australian (Perth, WA : 1879 – 1954), Saturday 17 December 1949, page 19

Music Club Resuming
The beautiful music room of “Minnawarra,” lovely old Peppermint Grove home, will be decorated with roses and poinsettias picked from the spacious gardens tonight when the Minnawarra Music Club hold the first of four winter meetings. Members will be welcomed in the entrance hall by the honorary organiser, Mr. Marshall Sumner and charming Club patroness, Mrs. Helen Watson-Williams. Guest artists will be Elisabeth Munro-George (pianist), Alice Malton (soprano), Kathleen Moore (oboe), Alan Rule and Robert Trew (clarinets), William Cathcart (bassoon) and Harold Thornton, (French horn).
Sunday Times (Perth, WA : 1902 – 1955), Sunday 11 June 1950, page 9
1950
When Allan’s student Jack Harrison was asked to fill the second clarinet position in the South Australian Symphony Orchestra in October 1950, Allan gave him these:


1951



The Chamber Music Society of W.A. will hold an open air concert for members and guests in the garden of Mr. and Mrs. W. Evans, 3a View-street, Peppermint Grove, tomorrow evening. The programme will be presented by Alan Rule (clarinet), Don Cartwright (oboe), John Cran (bassoon), Stephanie James (piano). The works performed will be trios for oboe, clarinet and bassoon by Ibert, Milhaud and Flegier; a piano and bassoon sonata by Hurlstone; and a clarinet and bassoon sonata by Poulenc.
West Australian (Perth, WA : 1879 – 1954), Saturday 21 March 1953, page 21

PEOPLE YOU LISTEN TO – ALLAN RULE
Allan Rule has done very little teaching since he began work with the W.A. Symphony Orchestra. Before he taught at the Melbourne Conservatorium of Music. He has three pupils in W.A.. They are Jack Harrison, Peter Clinch and Don Westlake. Of Jack Harrison, Alan says “he’s the best pupil I’ve ever taught and ever hope to teach. He’s the cleverist and the slickest.” Alan said he was quite proud of all three pupils.
The Broadcaster 1953 page 16 – from Jack Harrison’s scrap book
From the 1953 memoires of Neil Boon:
My lessons with Allan Rule the master teacher.
In the music scene the next three months (July 1953) were very exciting!!
I started lessons with Allan Rule, the principal clarinettist with WASO.
Alan was a big bloke with hands twice the size of mine. When he put his instrument in his mouth, it was as if by magic everything else in the world didn’t seem to matter anymore. His was the most beautiful clarinet sound I had ever heard. This was how a clarinet should sound! Whether he played loud or soft, fast or slow, high or low, there always was that pure and clear centre to his tone. His breath support was consistent and his tonguing was super clean, light and rapid, as well as being energetic or aggressive when it needed to be. This big man was a sensitive being with a superb sense of timing, tuning, phrasing and articulation. I was so lucky to have him as my teacher. This was what I’d been waiting for since I first heard about him during my ABC audition in 1951. When Mr. Rule (is what I called him at first) heard me play, his first comment was: “if you are prepared to work hard, maybe, just maybe, one day you will play the clarinet the way it should be played”.
I obviously hadn’t impressed him with my playing or my attitude. It took me some time to realise that, until I met Allan, I’d always been a big fish in a very small pond. Now I was being thrown in the big pond where I’d have to share the “limelight” with much bigger fish. If I wanted to become a professional clarinettist I first had to come down off my “high horse” and learn what it was to be humble and self-critical. No more applause for mediocre young Neil Boon. It was time to get serious, which meant going back to some of the basics, without feeling as though someone was deliberately “stepping on my willy”.
I told Mr. Rule I that was prepared to go back to basics where he thought it necessary. I made a sincere promise that I’d “work my guts out” to get to my best standard possible. “Fair enough, but don’t become a gutless wonder” was his reply. I wasn’t sure how to interpret this comment but I decided to let it rest.
Funny how I remember just about every word we exchanged on that particular day. Although I was rather taken aback by his criticism of my playing that day, I came away from his house elated and zestful, because I now had a Master-Teacher.
The second lesson with Mr. Rule!
Because of the search for land and the excitement of starting to build a house, my practice had been less than sufficient. I was rather worried that in the first week I hadn’t kept my promise to “work my guts out”.
When I told Allan how the circumstances of the last week had been rather unusual, his reaction was surprisingly mild. In fact, he said that I’d made good progress, but I shouldn’t for one moment think that I could get away with such little practice from now on. During the lesson I began to realise that there was a soft and caring side to this man’s character.
He spoke about the importance of self-confidence and determination.
It became obvious to me that he had done some research into the jazz work I had done over the last two years or so. I’m sure he’d had some contact with Harry Bluck, who of course was well informed regarding my experience in the jazz and dance band scene, both in Perth and the South West mill towns.
For the first time in my life I was made aware of the meaning of the educational terminology of “input and outcome”. Allan said that in regard to playing an instrument, most people think that when reading the music, the job is done when they respond correctly to the instructions on the page.
His words: “Real musicianship comes to the fore by listening to the outcomes of your inputs and deciding how to turn your actions into worthwhile and sensitive musical happenings. It’s all in your interpretation of the notes”.
Herewith Allan tried to make me aware of the need to develop musical awareness. He warned me that the jazz scene in Perth was heavily focused on “being famous” or at least on being well known, rather than being capable and musically proficient (I had noticed that the best known players weren’t necessarily the most capable). According to Allan this didn’t work in what he called “serious” music. I believed by serious music he meant artistic music compared to pop music. In Perth in the early fifties, jazz music was seldom recognised as being artistic, but unfortunately more often categorised with pop music, the music for the masses.
During the next couple of months Allan focussed heavily on sight-reading as well as absolute clarity of tonguing in the clarion register of the instrument.
I was told that I was an intensely stressed player, evident in the way in which I held my instrument. His words were: “you have only one holding finger and nine playing fingers. The task of your right-hand thumb in combination with your embouchure is to hold the instrument firmly. The other nine fingers are totally free to do whatever is needed to perform the required movements for an efficient playing technique. Any one of those nine fingers must never be used to hold or stabilise the instrument, in whatever way possible.
Allan set me to work on a couple of volumes of clarinet excerpts from the symphonic repertoire. After my second lesson with Allan the weekly one hours visit turned into two hour sessions. Each time when I came away from one of those sessions, I felt inspired and raring to go!


MELBOURNE – ON THE GRAPEVINE – With Geoff Brooke
BOON WILL BOOM WITH HIS BOOP-BOOP-A-DOO
One night last week I had the pleasure of working with a young musician who has just arrived here from Perth, and I have no hesitation in naming him as one of the most promising clarinettists in town today. He is 19 year old Neil Boon and his very easy style (which shows a distinct Goodman influence) and excellent tone, had the boys in the Joe Marchesani trio very enthusiastic indeed concerning his future prospects in the music game. The boy’s playing was full of ideas and his technique is a tribute to the thorough teaching of Alan Rule in Perth. Rule was well known to Melbourne theatre audiences as a member of the Regent orchestra for years and built an excellent reputation here as a teacher, before returning to home in the West. He is a big husky fellow and a fine player himself. Another of his prize pupils who is frequently mentioned when swing musicians are discussing the country’s top clarinet men is Jack Harrison of Perth, whose sister Jill was recently appointed to the Melbourne Symphony Orchestra in the bassoon chair.
The Argus Melbourne Saturday March 31 1956






Allan Rule retired in 1971.
Allan Rule died on 2nd February 1990.
Sad Loss for WA music
W.A. lost a much loved elder statesman of music last week with the death at age 82 of clarinettist Alan Rule.
Alan Rule came to Perth from Melbourne in 1949 to serve as Principal Clarinet with a W.A. Symphony Orchestra a position he held until 1967 when he was replaced by Jack Harrison.
He remained a member of the Orchestra until 1971.
Throughout his career, Alan Rule was a dedicated teacher – he continued to teach up to his death – and was regarded as a “father figure” in the Orchestra. His pupils have gone onto principal positions elsewhere: Don Westlake with the Sydney Symphony and Duncan Abercrombie with the Tasmanian Symphony.
W.A. Symphony spokesperson Lyn Schwan said yesterday Mr. Rule was highly praised in 1954 by Sir John Barbarolli and one of the many highlights of his career was performing Schubert’s Shepherd on the Rock with American Negro soprano Leotyne Price.
The West Australian Wednesday February 14 1990
“The last of the outstanding teachers was Alan Rule. He was taught by his father, who played in one of Melbourne’s theatre orchestras. Alan was Principal in the West Australian Symphony Orchestra at Perth from 1947 to 1967. He was the teacher in their early formative years of Peter Clinch, Jack Harrison and Don Westlake.”
“Don was born in Perth on 5 June 1931…Don’s first teacher was Percy Newton, then followed with lessons from Alan Rule, Stockigt and Simson”.
“Having almost identical beginnings with Don Westlake is Jack Harrison. Like Don, he was born at Perth in 1931 and like him was taught first by Percy Newton and then Alan Rule. Unlike Don, he has spent practically all his life in Perth and since 1951 has been a member (Principal since 1967) of the ABCs West Australian Symphony Orchestra.
Weston, Pamela, Clarinet Virtuosi of Today, (Egon,1989), p. 305
Notable students of Allan Rule include:
Grant Rickman